GST implications
As to “separate supply” in the current Agreement for Sale and Purchase of a Business.
Coffeys provide this information as a guideline only, all parties should seek professional legal and tax advice for confirmation of this interpretation.
In the latest edition of the Agreement for Sale and Purchase of a Business, Schedule 3 has been removed and warnings included in the document as to potential GST implications of residential accommodation forming any part of the sale. The now removed Schedule 3 included a declaration by the purchaser that they intended to use part of the property as a principal place of residence. It was silent on the implications of that however.
The Real Estate Institute of New Zealand has suggested the following clause, which is now to be included in the Further Terms of Sale of the Agreement (for Business Agreements) as follows:
SPECIAL GST CLAUSE DEALING WITH RESIDENCE – Clause 12 of this Agreement is substituted for the following:
20.1 If the sale evidenced by the Agreement includes any interest in land, and
- any part of the land is being used as a principal place of residence at the date of this agreement; and
- that part is still being so used at the time of supply under this Agreement; then the supply of that part will be a separate supply in accordance with section 5(15)(a) of the GST Act.
20.2 If the Purchaser warrants, or the Purchaser expects any nominee to warrant that at settlement:
- they will be a registered person; and
- they intend to use the land for making taxable supplies; and
- they intend to use part of the land as a principal place of residence for themselves and/or for any person associated with them under section 2A(1)(c) of the GST Act (persons connected by blood relationship, by marriage, civil union or de facto relationship, or by adoption); and
- the part is the same part as that being used as a principal place of residence at the time of supply under this Agreement; then the relevant references under this Agreement to ‘the supply’ shall mean the supply under this Agreement excluding that part of the land being used as a principal place of residence.
So, what are the implications of this?
5(15)(a) of the GST Act states:
When either of the following supplies are included in a supply, they are deemed to be a separate supply from the supply of any other real property that is included in the supply:
- a supply of a principal place of residence:
- a supply referred to in section 14(1)(d)
Section 14(1)(d) states supplies that are exempt from GST include:
The supply, being a sale, by any registered person in the course or furtherance of any taxable activity of—
- any dwelling; or
- the reversionary interest in the fee simple estate of any leasehold land,—
that has been used by the registered person for a period of 5 years or more before the date of the supply exclusively for the making of any supply or supplies referred to in paragraph (c) or paragraph (ca):
c) the supply of accommodation in any dwelling by way of—
- hire; or
- a service occupancy agreement; or
- a licence to occupy:
ca) the supply of leasehold land by way of rental (not being a grant or sale of the lease of that land) to the extent that that land is used for the principal purpose of accommodation in a dwelling erected on that land:
We were not aware of any issues with GST on the sale of going concern accommodation businesses in recent times, so were initially confused as to why such strong warnings were included in the new agreement.
In conclusion, it would seem that the residential portion of the sale is exempt from GST, whereas the balance of the sale, being a taxable activity, is zero rated for GST. This may explain why we have not heard of any GST issues arising on settlement and have never had a request for a theoretical apportionment as to the value of the residential component.
Kelvyn Coffey
Principal
© 2017
Previous Posts
Infometrics - AirBnB Guest Nights
Airbnb’s explosive growth has been integral in helping to ease accommodation bottlenecks in the New Zealand tourism sector over the past year.
Insurance - How Well Do You Know Your Policy?
With the recent earthquakes still fresh in mind, it would seem timely to consider insurance matters for natural disaster cover.
Management Rights
The intention of this article is to provide a brief overview of the operation of Management Rights in New Zealand.
Valuation of Accommodation Businesses
How do we appraise accommodation businesses?
Selling Your Accommodation Business - How Hard Can It Be?
Selling any type of business is usually quite different to selling a house.
Motel Rent Reviews
Most motels in New Zealand operate by way of leasing and likely many other types of accommodation properties as well. One of the main reasons for this, could be that the return from the real estate investment (land & buildings) is considerably lower than that earned by the operator of the business.
Depreciation
A painful recovery?
Appraisal of Shorter Term Motel Leases
Addressing how a motel with a shorter lease length can be appraised or valued.
Bed & Breakfast Operations
A Popular Choice
Understanding the Commercial Accommodation Lease
The majority of new entrants to the motel or accommodation industry will have purchased their business by way of lease. For many, this will be their first encounter with a commercial lease and it often seems that some aspects of commercial leasing may not be fully understood.
Motel Land & Building Investments
Advantages over other types of property investment.
Financial Returns
When considering the purchase of a motel business for the first time, it could be helpful to gain an overview of the returns being offered by the current market. These notes are intended to outline the differences in return on investment for each situation.
Feasibility of Motels
Issues and questions commonly raised to the assessment of viability for motel and accommodation business leases.
Checklist for Selling Your Motel
Thinking of selling your motel? View our checklist.
The Tourism Property Buyers Guide
The Buyers Guide is a collection of various articles written at different times addressing the many aspects of buying and selling tourism property.
What You Get Is Where You Buy
Commentary on rates of return on investment for motel and accommodation businesses.
Management Rights - Recent Court of Appeal Decision
Court of Appeal Decision relating to the question of exclusive letting rights for Management Rights operators.
Agency Agreements
Signing Up To Sell Your Business
Preparing Your Motel Business For Sale
A summary on where to start when preparing your motel business for sale.
Lease Values & Extensions
Why Would I Sell A Freehold Property And Buy A Lease?
ANZ Inbusiness Magazine
ANZ Inbusiness article on the subject of running a motel or similar accommodation.